The short answer
The best ClickMagick alternative depends on why you are leaving. Hyros suits high-ticket and call-based sales, RedTrack suits affiliates and media buyers, Triple Whale suits ecommerce brands and Cometly suits B2B SaaS. Only RedTrack publishes its prices the way ClickMagick does.
When ClickMagick is the wrong tool
ClickMagick is good at what it was built for: tracking paid traffic to your own funnels and affiliate offers, and sending the real sales back to the ad platforms. It publishes every price and bills by the month.
People look for ClickMagick alternatives for four reasons, and each has a different answer.
The business sells on calls or at high ticket prices and wants someone else to set the tracking up. The business is an affiliate or media buyer running volume across many traffic sources, where a monthly visitor cap is the wrong unit. The business is an online store that wants its attribution next to margins and customer data. Or the business is B2B, where the sale happens in a CRM weeks after the click.
So this page has one pick for each, not a top four in order of score.
How we picked
We read the pricing pages and published terms of each tool on 27 October, and compared what the entry plan includes, how the price is set and what you can know before talking to sales. We did not run campaigns through any of them. Hyros has a full review with a score; the other three are covered here only. Our general method is on how we rate.
Best for high-ticket and call-based sales: Hyros
Best for high-ticket sales: Hyros, because it sells the tracking and the setup together and backs it with a guarantee.
Hyros has one plan with everything in it: a setup team, an AI analyst, full tracking with call tracking for booked calls and closed deals, and a connection to Claude through MCP. The price follows the revenue it tracks and is quoted on a 15-minute call. Hyros guarantees better ad ROI or you do not pay.
The trade is the contract. The term renews automatically unless you cancel at least 30 days before it ends, and refund requests must be made in writing within 90 days of the first charge. Our ClickMagick vs Hyros comparison goes through the differences point by point.
Best for affiliates and media buyers: RedTrack
Best for affiliates: RedTrack, because it is priced on events rather than visitors and publishes everything, including what you pay for going over.
Solo costs $169 a month for 5 million events and one user, Team $399 for 20 million and five users, Enterprise $999 for 75 million and fifteen. Every plan sends conversions back to the ad platforms, syncs ad spend, has unlimited campaigns and stop rules, and starts with a 14-day trial. Data is kept for 12, 24 or 36 months by plan. Overage on Team is listed at $0.035 per thousand events.
That last line is the difference with ClickMagick, which states no price above its visitor caps. On 27 October RedTrack also showed a Black Friday offer of 30 percent off a year paid upfront.
Best for ecommerce brands: Triple Whale
Best for online stores: Triple Whale, because it puts attribution inside a dashboard built around a store's own numbers.
Its free plan already includes the Triple Pixel with first and last click attribution and its AI assistant, Moby. Multi-touch attribution, custom dashboards and sending first-party data back to the ad platforms start on Foundation. Marketing mix modelling and incrementality testing sit on Enterprise, with SOC 2 Type 2.
None of the paid plans has a published price. Each starts with a booked walkthrough.
Best for B2B SaaS: Cometly
Best for B2B: Cometly, because it follows a lead from the first ad click to a closed deal in the CRM, which is where a B2B sale is actually made.
Cometly describes itself as built for B2B SaaS. Its Core plan includes a pixel and server-side tracking, multi-touch attribution, account journeys, a conversions API, an AI ads manager and more than 70 integrations. Enterprise adds CRM and warehouse sync with Snowflake and BigQuery.
Pricing is usage-based, sized to your monthly pageviews, and not published.
Published prices against quotes
Of the five tools on this page, two publish their prices: ClickMagick and RedTrack. Triple Whale publishes a free plan and quotes the rest. Hyros and Cometly quote everything.
Thirty seconds on a pricing page can save a week of sales calls.
A quote is not a reason to rule a tool out, especially at high ad spend, where the price often depends on volume anyway. But if you are leaving ClickMagick because you want a fixed number before you start, RedTrack is the only alternative here that gives you one, and ClickMagick itself may still be the better fit at a higher plan.